A Comprehensive Rebuttal of Answering-Ansar’s
Article on Umm Kulthoom’s Nikah

By: Ibn Al-Hashimi

Introduction to Rebuttal

Response to Chapter 1 entitled “Introduction”

Response to Chapter 2 entitled “The alleged marriage of Umar ibn al Khattab to Hadhrath Umme Kalthum binte Fatima (as) from the texts of Ahl’ul Sunnah”

Response to Chapter 3 entitled “Our objections to the Sunni traditions”

Kuff and Umm Kulthoom’s Marriage

Response to Chapter 4 entitled “The marriage from the annals of the Salaf Kingpins”

Response to Chapter 5 Entitled “Elucidation to the truth”

A Different Umm Kulthoom?

Response to Chapter 6 Entitled: “Afriki’s failed efforts to get the Shi’a to accept a Sunni narration”

Response to Chapter 7 Entitled “The authenticity of Furu al Kafi”

Response to Chapter 8 Entitled “The first Shi’a tradition”

Response to Chapter 9 entitled “The second Shi’a tradition”

Response to Chapter 10 Entitled “The third and fourth Shi’a tradition”

Response to Chapter 11 Entitled “Fifth Shi’a tradition”

Response to Chapter 12 Entitled “Offspring from this alleged marriage”

Response to Chapter 13 Entitled “The comments of Shi’a Ulema”

Conclusion to Rebuttal